Implement sibling annex building and extension logic
This commit introduces the `SiblingBuilder` and `SiblingExt` traits to manage the creation, invalidation, and atomic building of sibling annexes. It also adds new functionality for sampling, statistics, and improved documentation for sibling-related operations.
This commit is contained in:
1 parent
8296e3544c
commit
7c7d7615cb
12 files changed
+177
-103
No files matched your search
@@ -329,7 +329,34 @@ Global family-size histogram (`global` row): 34 047 616 087 families; sizes 1 /
|
||||
|
||||
**`_dist.phy` (not asked for).** 180 × 180, symmetric, values 0.456-0.99999, median 0.999; Spearman with the Mash matrix 0.9999998 and with the index overlap −0.95, so it carries Mash-like information, consistent with the `jaccard` default (not verified). `args::distance_to_compute` at HEAD computes no matrix for this command line; why the file exists is unknown (binary predating the change, or a leftover; not checked). Not used above.
|
||||
|
||||
**Not measured:** any tree-level effect (sCF, species monophyly, support at the interface nodes 209/216 where `sN` was 17 and 7); the separate contribution of entropy, quartet and pair balance (needs ablation runs: without `--entropy`, without `--pair-balance`, `--quartet` alone); variance between draws (one draw per setting); clade-stratified 4-way coverage; the new alignment has not been given to IQ-TREE.
|
||||
**Not measured:** any tree-level effect (sCF, species monophyly, support at the interface nodes 209/216 where `sN` was 17 and 7); the separate contribution of entropy, quartet and pair balance (needs ablation runs: without `--entropy`, without `--pair-balance`, `--quartet` alone); variance between draws (one draw per setting); clade-stratified 4-way coverage; the new alignment had not been given to IQ-TREE (done 2026-10-16: see the last measured section).
|
||||
|
||||
## Tree-level effect of the combined draw: sCF on three trees (measured 2026-10-16)
|
||||
|
||||
Closes the "not measured" item of the previous section (the combined alignment given to IQ-TREE). Three trees, all sCF by `--scfl 100 --cf-verbose`, model `GTR+G4+ASC`:
|
||||
|
||||
- **A** = `concord` (12/10): entropy-only draw, 180 genomes, 5 003 414 columns; `-t` + `-m` re-ran a full ML search (59 h).
|
||||
- **B** = `concord_quartet_balance`: combined draw (`--entropy 1 --quartet --pair-balance`), 180 genomes, 5 000 000 columns. Its log stops during the tree search (14/10), so the command that produced its `cf.*` (16/10) is not in the files; presumably `-te` on the 15/10 treefile as for G (unverified).
|
||||
- **G** = `scf_good`: same draw as B without the 3 data-poor genomes (*A. pyrenaica* PHA000543, *A. saussurei*, *A. triflora*), 177 genomes. 72 sites became invariant and were removed to satisfy ASC; the search (`concord_quartet_balance_good`, 107 iterations, 6 h 47 on 120 threads) crashed in the sCF step on the FASTA (`Assertion all_prob_const < 1.0`; cause untested, ASC with constant sites is a suspect). sCF were recomputed with `-te <treefile> -s <varsites.phy> -m GTR+G4+ASC --scfl 100`: **no search** (0 iterations, lnL −41 053 676.53 vs −41 053 676.41 from the search), 4 999 729 columns. A used `-t`, B/G a fixed tree: the protocols differ.
|
||||
|
||||
| | A | B | G |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| Branches | 177 | 177 | 174 |
|
||||
| Mean `sN` | 3 219 | 13 163 | 13 396 |
|
||||
| Branches with `sN` < 100 / < 1 000 | 13 / 50 | 0 / 5 | 0 / 2 |
|
||||
| Median sCF | 44.2 | 42.9 | 42.8 |
|
||||
| Branches with sCF < 40 / ≥ 70 | 74 / 28 | 67 / 26 | 69 / 25 |
|
||||
| *Primula* and *Androsace* monophyletic | no / no | no / no | yes / yes |
|
||||
|
||||
**Sampling effect (A → B, same 180 genomes).** `sN` ×4.5 and the scarcity is gone. Sites do not become more concordant: on the 113 shared bipartitions (of 177) median sCF 48.0 → 47.3 (44 up, 69 down). Robinson-Foulds 128: the draw rearranged the tree deeply. Consistent with the earlier reading that the intra-*Androsace* conflict is not a matter of site count; the number of branches with sCF < 40 % stays around 70.
|
||||
|
||||
**Interface nodes.** Of the old nodes 209/211/212/216/217 (`sN` 17 / 226 / 184 / 7 / 7) none exists in G. Node 208 survives with `sN` 190 → 5 218 (sCF 54.5 → 37.5). Six mixed clades remain in G (83 to 72 tips, 50 *Primula* + 22-33 *Androsace*), all with `sN` > 3 000.
|
||||
|
||||
**Effect of the 3 genomes (B → G, same draw).** RF 16 (166 of 174 shared), median sCF 43.2 → 43.6, median `sN` unchanged. In B, *A. pyrenaica* and *A. triflora* sit inside *Primula* (a clade of 52 tips = 50 *Primula* + these 2; each has a *Primula* sister, sCF 92 % and 52 %, `sN` 556 and 153); *A. saussurei* stays with *Androsace*. Removing them restores both monophylies and changes nothing else measurably: support for "too little data to place them" (data-poor section), not for contamination, though the latter is not excluded.
|
||||
|
||||
**Where A and G disagree (2026-10-16).** On the 177 common tips: 124 shared bipartitions, 50 only in A, 50 only in G. Differing bipartitions are weakly supported in both trees (median sCF 35.7 in A-only, 37.7 in G-only, versus 47.5-48.1 on the shared ones), so the disagreement sits where support was already low. Differences are mostly local: the closest bipartition of the other tree is 1 tip away for 25 of 50 A-only and 21 of 50 G-only splits (≤ 2 tips: 37 and 30); only 8 and 9 are 5+ tips apart. Greedy removal of the tip that lowers RF most: the first (*P. auricula* subsp. *serratifolia*) takes RF from 100 to 86, then about 2 per tip (*A. maxima*, *P. stricta* var. *obesior*, then ordinary tips); the top three are data-poor genomes. A bipartition separates a data-poor genome (the 5 left after the 3 removals) in 1 of 124 shared splits but in 23 of 50 A-only and 10 of 50 G-only splits; removing those 5 genomes gives RF 72, against 96.6 (range 90-100, 40 draws) for 5 random tips. So about 28 of the 100 differences trace to data-poor genomes, and the remaining 72 do not. Backbone: A has a clade of 50 *Primula* + 25 *Androsace* (sCF 76, `sN` 453), G one of 50 + 26 (sCF 73, `sN` 6 677): one tip apart. Genuine conflict: a clade of 72 *Androsace* exists in both trees (A: sCF 34, `sN` 17 127; G: sCF 38, `sN` 49 473) with 16 different tips, i.e. a topological disagreement carried by tens of thousands of sites in each, not a scarcity effect; consistent with the intra-*Androsace* conflict above.
|
||||
|
||||
**Not established.** Separate contribution of entropy / quartet / pair balance (no ablation); stability of the tree between two independent draws (one draw per setting; A → B shows the topology moves with the draw); whether the quartet-informative restriction biases branch lengths (ASC corrects for variable-only ascertainment, not for requiring two states each in two genomes; tree length 22.5 is not interpretable as substitutions/site).
|
||||
|
||||
## Open questions
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in new issue
Block a user