Refactor sampling algorithms and coverage metrics
Optimize family scanning and sampling plan calculation logic. Introduce new per-genome richness metrics and redefine the sampling fraction $r$ for improved analysis.
This commit is contained in:
1 parent
0e40e83fd1
commit
c226744405
3 files changed
+70
-10
No files matched your search
@@ -291,6 +291,46 @@ Added so the measurements this file reports no longer need ad hoc scripts, and s
|
||||
- `--shannon-summary`: `--shannon` and the summary share one traversal (`scan_family_entropies`, which replaces the loop that lived in `shannon_entropy_csv`); the summary keeps counts per (entropy kind, genomes present, genomes without ambiguity, 0.05-bit bin) instead of one line per family: 156 lines for the 46 706 families of the testbed (a few hundred thousand lines at most on any index, by construction: the bins are bounded). Checked: its `entropy15` counts sum to the number of variable families.
|
||||
- Writers are in `cmd/phylo/stats.rs`; the library computes, the command layer formats and writes.
|
||||
|
||||
## Combined draw on Primulaceae: `--quartet --pair-balance --entropy 1` (measured 2026-10-13)
|
||||
|
||||
Command: `phylo --entropy 1 --pseudo-alignment --n-sites 5000000 --free-loss --no-ambiguity --quartet --pair-balance -o primulaceae_quartet_balance --family-overlap --sibling-stats primulaceae`. One draw, 180 genomes, 5 000 000 columns requested and obtained (no shortfall; no `--sample-plan`, so per-layer quotas are not inspectable). The three options are on together: **effects of entropy, quartet and pair balance are not separable here**; the testbed result that the entropy kernel adds nothing at small budgets was not rechecked.
|
||||
|
||||
**Baseline.** The same statistics were recomputed with one script on the alignment fed to IQ-TREE (`primulaceae-gamma_alignment.fasta`, 5 003 414 columns). It reproduces the figures of the earlier sections (sample overlap min 4 / median 1 665 / max 387 057 / CV 1.57; sampling fraction $r$ quantiles 0.0025 / 0.0037 / 0.0055; 5.2 % median calls per genome), hence **is the entropy-drawn sample** (`--entropy 1 --entropy-sd 0.5`, section on entropy bias), not a uniform draw. The "uniform draw" label of the nesting section is inconsistent with this (to settle). So the comparison below is *entropy-only vs entropy + quartet + pair balance*, never against a uniform control. A call is any character other than `?`/`-`. With `--free-loss` absence is written `?` (`masking::masked_state`); `-` only occurs without it. Neither file contains IUPAC characters.
|
||||
|
||||
| | Baseline (entropy only) | Combined |
|
||||
|---|---|---|
|
||||
| Informative columns (≥ 2 bases, each in ≥ 2 genomes) | 21.4 % | 100 % |
|
||||
| Carriers per column: median / share ≤ 4 / share ≥ 33 | 4 / 58.1 % / 8.0 % | 8 / 12.4 % / 11.3 % |
|
||||
| Calls per genome, median; genomes < 1 % / < 2 % | 5.2 %; 8 / 23 | 8.1 %; 4 / 6 |
|
||||
| Sample pair overlap min / median / max | 4 / 1 665 / 387 057 | 282 / 27 380 / 491 038 |
|
||||
| Sample overlap CV; max/min | 1.57; 96 764 | 1.10; 1 741 |
|
||||
| 4-way count (20 000 random quartets, 2 seeds): median | 200-202 | 3 738-3 797 |
|
||||
| 4-way p1 / p10 | 3 / 66-67 | 93-95 / 1 092-1 104 |
|
||||
| 4-way p90 / p99 | 3 000-3 644 / 65 700-67 300 | 14 500-15 600 / 82 900-84 600 |
|
||||
| 4-way CV; share of quartets with 0 | 3.4-3.5; 0.11-0.14 % | 1.83-1.87; 0 % |
|
||||
|
||||
(p90/p99 move by 20 % between the two seeds: read them as orders of magnitude only.) The gain is at the bottom of the 4-way distribution (median ×19, p1 ×30); the top is unchanged. 4-way coverage is not stratified by clade depth here (needs the tree). "Informative" is measured over the 180 genomes: a column informative overall is not necessarily informative among the four genomes of a given quartet.
|
||||
|
||||
**Pair representation.** Index-wide overlap used for the comparison: baseline, the raw matrix (`primulaceae_phylo_family_overlap.csv`); combined, the `--no-ambiguity` matrix of the same run. Different conventions, so the two slopes are indicative.
|
||||
|
||||
| | Baseline | Combined |
|
||||
|---|---|---|
|
||||
| Slope of log(sample overlap) on log(index overlap) | 1.12 ($R^2$ 0.997) | 0.54 ($R^2$ 0.91) |
|
||||
| Pairs with index overlap > 0 and no sample column | 0 | 0 |
|
||||
| Median $r$ = sample/index, poorest decile of index overlap | 0.0027 | 0.059 |
|
||||
| Median $r$, richest decile | 0.0053 | 0.0067 |
|
||||
| Median $r$ by decile 1 → 10 | 0.0027 … 0.0053, rising | 0.059, 0.065, 0.067, 0.067, 0.069, 0.074, 0.023, 0.0082, 0.0077, 0.0067 |
|
||||
|
||||
The weight does not merely flatten: the poorest pairs are now about 9× better represented (relative to their pool) than the richest, where the baseline gave them about half. Deciles 1-6 are flat; the drop sits at deciles 7-10, around the gap of the index-overlap distribution already noted in the entropy-bias section (cause of that gap still unchecked). **Caveat on $r$:** the numerator only holds quartet-informative families while the denominator counts every variable family, and the matrices differ in convention, so $r$ is no longer a sampling fraction of one pool; the decile pattern is a measurement of the sample, not of an inclusion probability.
|
||||
|
||||
**Per-genome richness.** `--sibling-stats` now gives the variable families (size ≥ 2) per genome: 0.72 M to 93.9 M, median 34.5 M. Spearman between a genome's calls in the sample and its variable-family count: **0.974 in the baseline, 0.435 in the combined draw**: the baseline mirrored genome richness, the combined draw largely decouples from it (on the same genomes the correlation with *all* families is 0.66 and 0.32). Genomes poorest in variable families: *A. saussurei* 0.72 M (0.30 % of its families), *A. triflora* 1.26 M (0.72 %), *P. stricta var. obesior* 2.39 M (1.33 %), then *P. pumila* 5.2 M, *P. auricula* subsp. *serratifolia* 5.9 M (1.92 %), *P. carniolica* 6.8 M (1.77 %), *A. pyrenaica* PHA000543 8.4 M (1.46 %). Their calls in the sample went from 6 986 / 1 936 / 2 403 (saussurei, triflora, stricta) to 15 725 / 22 988 / 25 392, and carniolica from 4 937 to 52 310; *saussurei* stays the poorest genome in both. These genomes are data-poor, not empty: their families are mostly of size 1. This is the per-genome $c_i$ the normalisation of the data-poor section calls for.
|
||||
|
||||
Global family-size histogram (`global` row): 34 047 616 087 families; sizes 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 = 33 512 358 231 (98.43 %) / 479 910 992 (1.41 %) / 45 621 663 (0.13 %) / 9 725 201 (0.03 %). Sizes ≥ 2 sum to 535 257 856, matching the 535 257 857 of the entropy table within 1.
|
||||
|
||||
**`_dist.phy` (not asked for).** 180 × 180, symmetric, values 0.456-0.99999, median 0.999; Spearman with the Mash matrix 0.9999998 and with the index overlap −0.95, so it carries Mash-like information, consistent with the `jaccard` default (not verified). `args::distance_to_compute` at HEAD computes no matrix for this command line; why the file exists is unknown (binary predating the change, or a leftover; not checked). Not used above.
|
||||
|
||||
**Not measured:** any tree-level effect (sCF, species monophyly, support at the interface nodes 209/216 where `sN` was 17 and 7); the separate contribution of entropy, quartet and pair balance (needs ablation runs: without `--entropy`, without `--pair-balance`, `--quartet` alone); variance between draws (one draw per setting); clade-stratified 4-way coverage; the new alignment has not been given to IQ-TREE.
|
||||
|
||||
## Open questions
|
||||
|
||||
- Per-family $S_f$ without materializing the full matrix: a first pass storing only a per-family summary (reach, $|S_f|$), as `--shannon` already does a full unsampled scan for entropy.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in new issue
Block a user