Proposes replacing the single-threaded niffler/flate2 pipeline in `obiread::xopen` with `rapidgzip-rs` for local `.gz` files. Details constraints such as path dependencies, non-seekable streams, C++ toolchain requirements, and binding maturity. Marks the optimization as parked pending throughput and correctness validation.
6.8 KiB
Chunk reader — implementation
obiread exposes two distinct sequence reading paths, each optimised for a different use case.
Two reading paths
| Path | API | Output unit | Per-record identity | Use case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Record path | read_sequence_chunks → parse_chunk |
SeqRecord (id + raw sequence + normalised rope) |
yes | query — must read complete records |
| Stream path | open_nuc_stream |
NucPage (flat normalised byte buffer) |
no | index, superkmer — bulk throughput |
The record path uses Rope-backed chunks and is described in detail below.
The stream path (NucStream / NucPage) is described in the scatter section of pipeline.
Record path: chunk reader
The chunk reader reads FASTA or FASTQ files in fixed-size blocks and yields self-contained chunks, each ending on a complete sequence record boundary. parse_chunk then converts each chunk into a Vec<SeqRecord>, where each record carries its identifier, raw sequence bytes, and a normalised rope ready for superkmer building.
This path is mandatory for query, where superkmers must be tracked back to their originating sequence (id, kmer offset) for output annotation.
Output type: Rope
Each chunk is a Rope — a segmented byte sequence: a Vec of blocks, where each block is a Vec<Cell<u8>>. The consumer iterates over the blocks via a forward or backward cursor.
Rope::split_off(pos) splits at an absolute byte offset in O(log n) (binary search over block-start index). If pos falls inside a block, that block is split in two via Vec::split_off — no memcpy in the common case.
SeqChunkIter
pub struct SeqChunkIter<R: Read> { /* private */ }
impl<R: Read> Iterator for SeqChunkIter<R> {
type Item = io::Result<Rope>;
}
pub fn fasta_chunks<R: Read>(source: R) -> SeqChunkIter<R>
pub fn fastq_chunks<R: Read>(source: R) -> SeqChunkIter<R>
next() loop:
1. read one block of block_size bytes → push onto Rope
2. call splitter(rope) → Option<abs_offset>
if Some(pos):
tail = rope.split_off(pos) ← O(log n), may split one block
chunk = mem::replace(&mut rope, tail)
return Some(Ok(chunk))
3. if EOF and rope non-empty: return Some(Ok(rope)) as final chunk
4. if EOF and rope empty: return None
The Splitter function signature is fn(&Rope) -> Option<usize>. It returns the absolute byte offset of the start of the last complete record, or None if no boundary was found in the accumulated rope (need more data).
Boundary detection — FASTA
Backward scan with a 2-state machine. Searches (right to left) for > followed by \n or \r (i.e., a > that is preceded by a newline in forward order):
stateDiagram-v2
direction LR
[*] --> Scanning
Scanning --> FoundGt : '>'
FoundGt --> Scanning : other
FoundGt --> [*] : '\\n' / '\\r' ✓
Returns the byte offset of the > that starts the last complete record. Returns None if only one > is found (cannot confirm there is a prior complete record).
Boundary detection — FASTQ
FASTQ records have a rigid 4-line structure (@header, sequence, +, quality). The @ character (ASCII 64, Phred score 31) can appear legitimately in quality lines, making any forward heuristic unreliable. The backward scanner verifies the full structural context before accepting a candidate @.
7-state machine (states 0–6), scanning from right to left. Each time a + is found, its position is saved as restart; any state mismatch resets the scan to that position.
stateDiagram-v2
direction LR
[*] --> Scanning
Scanning --> FoundPlus : '+' (save restart)
FoundPlus --> AfterNlPlus : '\\n' / '\\r'
FoundPlus --> Scanning : other → backtrack
AfterNlPlus --> AfterNlPlus : séparateur
AfterNlPlus --> InSequence : lettre / - / . / [ / ]
AfterNlPlus --> Scanning : other → backtrack
InSequence --> AfterSequence : '\\n' / '\\r'
InSequence --> InSequence : lettre / - / . / [ / ]
InSequence --> Scanning : other → backtrack
AfterSequence --> AfterSequence : '\\n' / '\\r'
AfterSequence --> InHeader : other
InHeader --> FoundAt : '@' (save cut)
InHeader --> Scanning : '\\n' / '\\r' → backtrack
InHeader --> InHeader : other
FoundAt --> [*] : '\\n' / '\\r' ✓
FoundAt --> InHeader : other
restart is updated each time a + is found. When any state fails its expected input, the scan jumps back to restart and continues from there — guaranteeing that a @ in a quality line cannot be accepted as a record start, because the \n+\n structure immediately following it (going backward) will not be found.
Returns the byte offset of the @ that starts the last complete record.
Future work — parallel gzip decompression in xopen
obiread::xopen (xopen.rs) decompresses gzip via niffler → flate2, which is single-threaded (standard DEFLATE has no parallel-decodable structure). For large local gzip inputs this single-threaded decompression can become the throughput bottleneck feeding the query/index/superkmer pipelines, since chunk/page production for a given file is serialized ahead of the worker pool.
Candidate: special-case local, on-disk, gzip-magic-detected paths in open_raw/xopen to use rapidgzip-rs (ReaderBuilder::new().parallelism(n).open(path), implements Read + Seek) instead of niffler, keeping niffler for every other case: stdin (-), HTTP(S) sources, and all non-gzip formats (bzip2, xz, zstd — less used in practice here).
Constraints identified so far (not yet validated against real data):
- Branch point must move earlier than the current
decompress()call inopen_raw— rapidgzip's fast path needs the file path, not an already-opened genericRead, so the gzip/local-file detection has to happen before the genericFile::open+niffler::send::get_readerpath is taken. stdinand HTTP sources are not seekable — they stay onnifflerregardless; the gain only applies to local on-disk.gzfiles.rapidgzip-sysvendors a native C++ engine: requires CMake ≥ 3.17, a C++17 compiler, andnasmon x86 targets — a real build-toolchain addition, not just a pure-Rust crate.- Low maturity of the Rust binding at review time (2 GitHub stars, ~15 commits, April 2026 latest release) — the underlying C++ engine is validated (HPDC 2023 paper), but the binding itself has limited production track record.
Decision: parked for now. Before adopting, validate on real data: throughput vs. niffler on representative large .gz inputs, and byte-for-byte correctness of decompressed output.